Birth Mother Autonomy Shapes the Future of Adoption

Daliya Brown's three adoption experiences demonstrate why birth mother autonomy must be respected in adoption decisions. Her journey from Pennsylvania to Utah for placement, combined with her experiences in both agency-supported and private adoptions, provides insight into why women need individualized support rather than restrictive, blanket policies.

In a recent episode of Choosing Adoption, host Donna Pope facilitates a conversation with Daliya Brown about the importance of respecting birth mothers' decision-making capabilities. Daliya's experiences challenge assumptions about women's ability to make informed choices about their bodies, their children, and their adoption plans.

According to the Adoption Network, approximately 95% of domestic infant adoptions are considered open adoptions, requiring coordination between birth mothers, adoptive families, and service providers. Daliya's story illustrates why this coordination must center on respecting birth mother autonomy rather than imposing external limitations. Respecting birth mother autonomy is essential in the adoption process to ensure every woman has the freedom to make informed adoption choices.

The Reality of Individual Circumstances  

Daliya Brown's multiple adoption experiences highlight why birth mother autonomy matters in practical terms. She explains that her decision to travel to Utah was based on research showing that Pennsylvania had more complex legal requirements that could burden adoptive families. Rather than being coerced, she made an informed choice to facilitate a smoother process for everyone involved.

The U.S. Census Bureau reports that mothers experience an average earnings drop of $1,861 in the first quarter after birth, making practical considerations about timing, location, and support systems particularly important for women facing unplanned pregnancies.

Daliya Brown's experience traveling to Utah for her first placement demonstrates how quickly arrangements can be made when women have agency support. She contacted the agency and was in Utah within a day, giving birth just two days after arrival. This rapid response was possible because the agency respected her autonomy and accommodated her decision rather than creating bureaucratic barriers.

Agency Support Versus Private Adoption  

Daliya Brown's comparison between agency-supported and private adoption arrangements illustrates why birth mother autonomy requires proper advocacy. She describes private adoption as lacking the support systems that agencies provide, leaving birth mothers without advocates to represent their interests.

Private vs agency adoption often comes down to how well birth mothers receive advocacy and post-placement support. According to American Adoptions, birth mothers deserve proper legal representation and support throughout the adoption process, which private arrangements often fail to provide. Daliya Brown's experience confirms this, noting that private adoption felt geared toward the adoptive family's needs rather than ensuring birth mother autonomy and support.

FindLaw reports that about two-thirds of domestic infant adoptions experience continued post-placement contact, making it essential that birth mothers have advocates helping them establish boundaries and communication preferences that respect their autonomy.

Waiting Periods and Birth Mother Autonomy  

Daliya Brown's perspective on mandatory waiting periods provides insight into how these policies can either support or undermine birth mother autonomy. Having experienced both Utah's 24-hour waiting period and Pennsylvania's 72-hour requirement, she notes that the timing didn't affect her decision-making process.

Her observation that women think about their adoption decision every time they feel the baby move throughout pregnancy challenges the assumption that post-birth waiting periods significantly impact decision-making. This perspective aligns with research showing that birth mothers typically make their decisions well before delivery.

Texas Adoption Center notes that state laws vary significantly regarding consent timing and revocation periods, but Daliya Brown's experience suggests that respecting birth mother autonomy matters more than specific timeframes.

Interstate Travel and Birth Mother Autonomy  

Daliya Brown's defense of interstate travel options demonstrates why geographic restrictions undermine birth mother autonomy. She argues that women should have the right to choose where to give birth and which agencies to work with, regardless of state boundaries.

Her practical considerations about traveling with newborns and the impact on adoptive families with other children illustrate why birth mother autonomy includes the right to choose arrangements that work best for everyone involved. Adoption Services explains that interstate adoptions require approval from both states through the Interstate Compact Office, ensuring legal oversight while preserving options for families.

Families Rising reports that the Interstate Compact on Adoption and Medical Assistance (ICAMA) facilitates the transfer of benefits between states, with 49 states and the District of Columbia as members, supporting the infrastructure that makes interstate adoption viable when women choose this option.

Hospital Policies and Birth Mother Autonomy  

Daliya Brown's experience with hospital guardianship papers illustrates how institutional policies can either support or undermine birth mother autonomy. She describes situations where hospitals were reluctant to recognize guardianship documents that would allow adoptive families to make medical decisions and stay with babies beyond visiting hours.

These experiences highlight the importance of systems that respect birth mothers' legal authority to make decisions about their children's care during the immediate post-birth period. When hospitals don't recognize properly executed legal documents, they effectively override birth mother autonomy and create unnecessary complications.

Mount Sinai research shows that pregnancy-related expenses can create significant financial burden for families, making it essential that institutional policies support rather than complicate the arrangements birth mothers have made to ensure their children receive appropriate care.

Relationships and Birth Mother Autonomy  

Daliya Brown's evolving perspective on relationships with adoptive families demonstrates how birth mother autonomy includes the right to change one's mind about contact levels. After a difficult experience with one family, she initially wanted minimal contact with subsequent adoptive families but remained open to adjusting based on actual interactions.

Her decision to hold her third baby and allow her son to meet the adoptive family represents choices made from a position of autonomy rather than pressure. She emphasizes that these decisions felt natural and were respected by her support team.

Understanding open adoption arrangements is key to building trust and protecting birth mother rights throughout the adoption process. Research published in PMC indicates that open adoption arrangements are dynamic, with different levels of contact associated with different experiences and satisfaction levels. Daliya Brown's experience confirms that birth mother autonomy includes the right to establish and modify boundaries based on individual comfort levels and circumstances.

Addressing Misconceptions About Birth Mother Autonomy  

Daliya Brown directly challenges assumptions that birth mothers are incapable of making informed decisions. She points out that many birth mothers are already parents and adults who make difficult decisions regularly, particularly single mothers who navigate complex situations independently.

Her response to suggestions that birth mothers are being coerced emphasizes that these assumptions are insulting and inaccurate. She frames adoption decisions as selfless choices that benefit families who cannot conceive rather than decisions made under pressure or manipulation.

The National Council for Adoption notes that effective adoption policies should expand access to services rather than restrict options, supporting Daliya Brown's argument that birth mother autonomy requires options rather than limitations.

Policy Implications for Birth Mother Autonomy  

Daliya Brown's advice to policymakers emphasizes that individual circumstances vary too much for one-size-fits-all approaches. She uses the analogy of her labor experience, where hospital protocols didn't account for her body's individual patterns, to illustrate why policies affecting millions of women cannot be based on standardized assumptions.

Her argument that women are capable of making decisions about their own bodies and children challenges paternalistic approaches to adoption regulation. She questions why women are considered capable of working and paying taxes but somehow incapable of making informed decisions about pregnancy and adoption.

According to multiple sources, most states allow adoptive families to cover reasonable living expenses for birth mothers, but Daliya Brown's experience suggests that the focus should be on ensuring these supports respect birth mother autonomy rather than creating dependencies or restrictions.

Supporting Birth Mother Autonomy in Practice  

Daliya Brown's advice to agencies emphasizes the importance of listening to individual women's needs rather than imposing standard approaches. She notes that what feels supportive to one person may feel overwhelming to another, requiring flexibility and responsiveness from support teams.

Her example of preferring hotel accommodations over staying with adoptive families illustrates how birth mother autonomy includes the right to establish boundaries that may not align with others' preferences or assumptions about what constitutes appropriate support.

Lifetime Adoption research shows that birth mothers who receive counseling during the adoption process are more confident in their decisions, resulting in reclaim rates of only 3-4% compared to higher rates when proper support isn't provided, suggesting that respecting birth mother autonomy and providing appropriate support leads to better outcomes for everyone.

Moving Forward with Respect for Birth Mother Autonomy  

Daliya Brown's experiences demonstrate that respecting birth mother autonomy leads to better outcomes for birth mothers, adoptive families, and children. Her story challenges narratives that frame women as incapable of making informed decisions about their own bodies and children's futures.

The key elements that supported Daliya Brown's positive experiences - agency advocacy, respect for her preferences, flexible arrangements, and recognition of her decision-making authority - provide a model for adoption practices that truly center birth mother autonomy.

Wikipedia notes that approximately 18,000 independent adoptions occur annually, representing families formed through various pathways that require thoughtful support and respect for birth mother autonomy rather than paternalistic restrictions. Explore why birth mother autonomy is essential in ethical adoption practices. Learn how policies and support systems impact women’s adoption choices and outcomes.

Ready to learn more about supporting birth mother autonomy and real stories from the adoption community? Subscribe to Choosing Adoption for conversations that explore how respecting women's decision-making capabilities creates better outcomes for everyone involved.

Follow or Subscribe to Choosing Adoption on your favorite platforms:

Website | YouTube | Twitter/X | Instagram

Follow Donna Pope

#Adoption #AdoptionJourney #BirthMother #OpenAdoption #AdoptionStories #BirthMotherAutonomy #RespectBirthMothers #AdoptionChoices #AdoptionSupport #AdoptionAdvocacy #AdoptionPolicy #FamilyThroughAdoption #EveryStoryMatters #AdoptionCommunity #AdoptionAwareness #EmpowerBirthMothers #AdoptionSupportNetwork #WomenSupportingWomen #EthicalAdoption #AdoptionLove